When the makeup wears off: A dispute over expectations

JOHANNESBURG ‑ In a peculiar case that highlights the complexities of modern relationships, Benmore resident Johnathan Davis has filed a complaint against an unnamed woman, claiming that she misrepresented her physical appearance, leading him to engage in a romantic encounter under false pretenses.

According to Davis's lawyer, the incident occurred after the pair met at a popular Sandton bar and spent the remainder of the evening together – at his place. Davis alleges that the woman’s appearance under dim lighting and with excessive makeup led him to believe she was more attractive than she actually is. When the pair woke up the next morning, Davis claims he was shocked and disappointed by her "true appearance."

“It’s like thinking you’re buying a Ferrari, then end up driving an old Beetle of the showroom floor,” said Davis during an interview with The Gray News.

Davis’s lawyer said that he is seeking compensation for emotional distress and damages, citing "deceptive practices" and “false advertising” in the woman’s presentation of herself. However, legal experts are skeptical about the merits of the case, questioning whether such claims can be considered legitimate grounds for a lawsuit.

The unnamed woman’s representatives have declined to comment on the matter.

This unusual case raises questions about the boundaries of personal responsibility and the expectations that come with dating. As the situation unfolds, it remains to be seen how the parties involved will navigate the complexities of their encounter.

True story!